California Assembly Bill 5 and its Impact on the Film Industry

By Nina Ameri, Entertainment Attorney 
Date
March 21, 2024
Category
Production
Reading time

~3 min

Nina Ameri, founding attorney of Ameri Law PC

Written and Reviewed by Nina Ameri — Founder, Ameri Law, PC

(21 years of experience, Entertainment & Intellectual Property Law, Film & TV Deals, Influencer Law, Advisor to Film Fatales and AEB)

Under California’s AB5, film crew and talent are presumed to be employees rather than independent contractors unless the production can prove all three parts of the ABC test or a specific exemption applies. Productions can reduce misclassification risk by contracting through loan-out companies, avoiding work-made-for-hire clauses, and using a payroll company.

What Is California AB5 and How Does It Affect Film Productions?

The law, enacted in 2019 and later amended in 2020, brought significant changes to the entertainment industry with respect to freelance independent contractors working on films. This legislation changed how companies were meant to classify workers. Individuals previously deemed W-9 independent contractors were now suddenly considered W-2 employees. Understanding the bill’s intricacies is essential for producers and production entities engaging key crew and talent for California film projects.

What Is the ABC Test?

The ABC Test, a codified cornerstone of AB5, mandates that a worker be classified as an employee unless the hiring entity can prove these three conditions are met: 

Control and Direction: The worker is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity in the performance of their work. 

Work Outside Usual Business: The work performed by the individual is outside the hiring entity’s usual course of business. 

Independent Trade, Occupation, or Business: The worker is engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business. 

Why Is AB5 Hard for Film Productions to Navigate?

For industries like film production, where a production company needs control and direction to ensure a project runs smoothly, classifying crew and talent as independent contractors is a challenge. Determining whether workers should be treated as employees or independent contractors requires applying the ABC Test, which courts and labor agencies use alongside the Borello test to assess the true nature of the working relationship. The law requires a nuanced approach to avoid misclassification, which can lead to severe financial penalties that will hinder any project’s development.

How Can Producers Reduce AB5 Misclassification Risk?

To navigate these challenges, producers and production entities have a few options when constructing their agreements with talent and crew members: 

Exclusive Engagement of Loan-Out Companies:

Contracting exclusively with a worker’s loan-out company significantly mitigates the risk of misclassification as this avoids creating a direct-hire relationship with the individual worker. By contracting instead with the individual’s loan-out company (usually an LLC), there is a chance that the relationship would  qualify under AB5’s business-to-business exemption. 

Abstaining from WMFH Clauses:

It is important for hiring companies to make sure they own the rights and proceeds of the services provided by cast and crew, therefore, “work made for hire” provisions (“WMFH”) are typically seen in agreements. However, under the California Labor Code, including a WMFH clause in an independent contractor agreement will transform that contractor into a statutory employee. Opting for an assignment of rights provision instead may avoid triggering immediate statutory employee classification. 

Allowing Limited Rights Retention:

Even if WMFH clauses are included in the agreement, modifying them to allow contractors to retain limited rights in the commissioned work may also prevent statutory employee misclassification. 

Should a Production Use a Payroll Company for AB5 Compliance?

Furthermore, when looking to hire talent and crew members, bringing in a payroll company can certainly streamline the onboarding process and help ensure AB5 compliance. In fact, the Screen Actors Guild (“SAG”) requires all SAG productions to use one of their pre-approved entertainment payroll companies. By engaging a payroll company, they can ensure compliance with federal and state employment laws. Choosing whether or not to use one depends on factors such as the complexity of the production, the specific services and commissioned work sought from cast and crew, budget, and the overall willingness to outsource payroll responsibilities. 

How Can an Attorney Help With AB5 Compliance?

Complying with AB5 requires a careful consideration of these options. By adopting the appropriate approach on a case-by-case basis, producers and production entities can adequately mitigate the risk of statutory employee misclassification and ensure safe passage through California’s evolving employment regulatory landscape. For help navigating this process, contact Ameri Law PC to receive guidance from our skilled entertainment attorneys today. 

AB5 FAQs

What is California Assembly Bill 5 (AB5) and when was it enacted?

California Assembly Bill 5 (AB5) was enacted in 2019 and later amended in 2020. It significantly changed how companies classify workers, particularly affecting freelance independent contractors in the film industry. 

The ABC Test is a key component of AB5 that mandates a worker be classified as an employee unless three conditions are met: the worker is free from the hiring entity’s control and direction, the work performed is outside the hiring entity’s usual course of business, and the worker is engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business.

AB5 poses challenges for the film industry because production companies need control and direction to ensure projects run smoothly. This makes it difficult to classify crew and talent as independent contractors, and misclassification can lead to severe financial penalties.

Producers and production entities can navigate AB5 compliance by engaging loan-out companies, avoiding “work made for hire” clauses, and hiring payroll companies. These options help mitigate the risk of misclassification and ensure compliance with AB5.

Hiring a payroll company can streamline the onboarding process and ensure AB5 compliance. The Screen Actors Guild (SAG) requires all SAG productions to use pre-approved entertainment payroll companies to ensure compliance with federal and state employment laws. 

Your Creative Vision Deserves Expert Legal Partnership

Building a successful career or business in entertainment requires a solid legal foundation. Get the strategic advice and diligent support you need to protect your work and thrive.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *